Hand-crafted Mustard - Butterfly Bakery

$8.99

Mustard like you've never had it before.

Handcrafted in Montpelier, these small, seasonal batches are ever-changing (read: check back often!) and feature random-as-heck flavor greatness.

Each 8 oz jar is made with organic Canadian yellow and brown mustard seed, organic white vinegar, and salt, plus whatever flavor is mentioned in the name and description — which makes selecting your favorite pretty darn easy.*

Butterfly Bakery is committed to slow, sustainable growth using local ingredients and paying their employees a living wage. Seriously, what's not to love?

*Except Gustard. Gustard is special. In collaboration with the musical awesomeness that is Guster (They just happen to be one of our owner's favorite bands. Look them up – you're welcome.), Gustard is a spicy pickle mustard. A percentage of proceeds is donated to Zeno Mountain Farm — one of the greatest places on earth.

Flavor: Heady Topper

Heady Topper Maple Sriracha Vermont Jalapeno Gustard Hard Cider Smoked Onion

Most items deliver free to anywhere in Vermont!

Keeping money local: Every purchase on Myti supports Vermont brands, retailers, and communities—keeping your dollars where they matter most.

We have paused shipping to states outside of Vermont, but hope to resume soon. Please sign up for our email list for updates!