Shopping Local, Made Easy

Myti will be closed on New Year's Day. Our team will be back on 1/2/2026. Happy New Year!

Cat Toys

Cat toys from local Vermont shops. Interactive toys, balls, and scratching toys to keep your cat playful and engaged, with fast local delivery across Vermont.

229 products

Doskocil Looney Loops Cat Toy by Pet Food Warehouse

Pet Food Warehouse

Doskocil Looney Loops Cat Toy

$4.49
$4.49 $0.00
PLAY Kitten Mittens

Houndstooth

PLAY Kitten Mittens

$10.99
$10.99
Peacock Feather Cat Toy by Pet Food Warehouse

Pet Food Warehouse

Peacock Feather Cat Toy

$1.79
$1.79 $0.00
Plastic Lattice Balls Cat Toy by Pet Food Warehouse

Pet Food Warehouse

Plastic Lattice Balls Cat Toy

$0.79
$0.79 $0.00
ZippyClaws Kickerz Mushroom Cat Toy by Pet Food Warehouse

Pet Food Warehouse

ZippyClaws Kickerz Mushroom Cat Toy

$4.49
$4.49 $0.00
Benebone Ring Bacon Medium by Pet Food Warehouse

Pet Food Warehouse

Benebone Ring Bacon Medium

$17.79
$17.79 $0.00
The Original Cat Dancer

Houndstooth

The Original Cat Dancer

$3.99
$3.99
Housecat Club Catnip Pie Slice Toy
Choose options

Houndstooth

Housecat Club Catnip Pie Slice Toy

$10.00
$10.00
Dr Pussum's Naughty Nips Mini Catnip Toy Set

Houndstooth

Dr Pussum's Naughty Nips Mini Catnip Toy Set

$11.99
$11.99
Simply B Vermont Kit Nip Kicker

Houndstooth

Simply B Vermont Kit Nip Kicker

$12.95
$12.95
Ciao Gatto Wool Felt Catnip Tortellini

Houndstooth

Ciao Gatto Wool Felt Catnip Tortellini

$22.00
$22.00
Karma Cat Wool Owls Cat Toy

Houndstooth

Karma Cat Wool Owls Cat Toy

$9.95
$9.95