Shopping Local, Made Easy

New: See local options while browsing Amazon, Walmart & more. Learn more.

Mulled Cider Caramel

$7.59

We teamed up with Cold Hollow Cider Mill for this delicious Mulled Cider Caramel! It is a rich, cozy, nuanced and robust caramel. It's amazing with coffee and tea. It's perfection on a Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Maple Gingersnap. And it's just pure delight on sliced apples. Cook the caramel a little longer and dip in an apple for the ultimate caramel apple.

Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses. Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces have a 18 month shelf life and should be refrigerated after opening.

🏆 AWARD WINNER 🏆
2025 Scovie Awards - Best Condiment - Not Hot & Spicy, Sweet Sauce - 1st Place

Size: 2oz

2oz 8oz 32oz

Stamped Bags (8oz and 2oz jars only): No bag

No bag Toad Spring Leaf Summer Flower Autumn Leaves Winter Snowflakes Happy Holidays Love

Most items deliver free to anywhere in Vermont!

Keeping money local: Every purchase on Myti supports Vermont brands, retailers, and communities—keeping your dollars where they matter most.

We have paused shipping to states outside of Vermont, but hope to resume soon. Please sign up for our email list for updates!

Every product you buy supports real Vermont businesses—keeping dollars, jobs, and creativity right here at home.

The joy of shopping Local,
delivered to your door!

If something's not right, we'll make it right. Our local support team is here to help-with real answers, not auto replies.

Mulled Cider Caramel