Skip to content

Delivery to Vermont

Shopping Local, Made Easy

Find a Store
Returns

Facebook
Instagram

Search

Sign in/ Register Cart

Shoes & Apparel
Women's Clothing
Shirts & Tops
Pants
Shorts
Activewear
Outerwear
Sleepwear
Socks
Kids
Shirts & Tops
Shorts
Pants
Outerwear
Baby & Toddler
Socks
Footwear

Women's Footwear
Running
Sneakers
Sandals
Boots
Slippers
All Footwear
Accessories
Hats
Scarves
Belts
Jewelry
Luggage & Bags
Handbags, Wallets & Cases
Gloves & Mittens
Sunglasses

Men's Clothing
Shirts & Tops
Shorts
Pants
Activewear
Outerwear
Sleepwear
Socks
Stores
Lenny's Shoe & Apparel
Alpine Shop
Harbor Thread
Dear Lucy
Kaden Apparel
Jennifer Khan Jewelry
Queen City Footwear

Men's Footwear
Running
Sneakers
Sandals
Boots
Slippers
All Footwear
Daily Essentials
Pantry & Kitchen
Coffee
Tea
Beverages
Candy & Chocolate
Condiments & Sauces
Maple Products
Seasonings & Spices
Dips & Spreads

Personal Care
Skin Care
Nutrition
Bath & Body
Bar Soap
Cosmetics
Hair Care

Pet Supplies
Pet Treats & Chews
Dog Food
Cat Food
Grooming Supplies
Pet Toys

Stores
Pet Food Warehouse
Brio Coffeeworks
Kiss the Cook
Homeport
Home
Household Essentials
Dishcloths
Soap
Moisturizer
Sunscreen

Kitchen & Dining
Cookware & Bakeware
Knives
Tools & Utensils
Storage & Jars
Appliances
Barware & Drinkware
Tableware

Furniture
Accent Furniture
Dining Furniture
Outdoor Furniture
Office Furniture
Upholstery

Bedding & Bath
Bedding
Bath Towels & Washcloths
Bathroom Accessories
Laundry

Home Décor
Candles
Lamps & Lighting
Rugs & Mats
Decorative Accents

Stores
Homeport
Kiss the Cook
AO Glass
Natural Mattress Company
Way Out Wax
Sports & Outdoors
Hike & Camp
Hiking Shirts
Hiking Shorts
Hiking Footwear
Gear and Accessories
Hydration

Biking
Bike Clothing
Bike Accessories
Bike Racks

Winter Sports
Ski & Snowboard Jackets
Snowboards, Boots & Bindings
Skis, Boots & Bindings
Cross-Country Skis & Boots

Stores
Lenny's Shoe & Apparel
Alpine Shop
Queen City Footwear
Pet Supplies
Dog Supplies
Treats
Collars & Leashes
Beds & Crates
Toys

Cat Supplies
Food & Treats
Litter & Accessories
Beds & Furniture
Toys

Small Animal Supplies
Bird Supplies
Food & Treats
Habitats & Cages

Stores
Pet Food Warehouse
Houndstooth
Waggle Woof and Wander
Alpine Shop
Food & Gifts
Gourmet Foods
Chocolates & Confections
Snacks & Nuts
Jams & Preserves
Sauces & Condiments
Beverages
Maple Syrup Products

Vermont Made
Glass
Candles
Shoes

Stores
Magpie & Tiger
SidePony Boutique
Wild Lark
Homeport

Myti Gift Cards
Books & Hobbies
Books & Music
Fiction
Non-Fiction
Young Adult
Children's Books
Cookbooks
Vinyl Records & LPs

Arts & Crafts
Knitting
Crafts & Activities

Games & Puzzles
Board Games
Puzzles
Toys

Stores
Phoenix Books
Autumn Records
Must Love Yarn
Homeport
Sale

Shoes & Apparel
- Women's Clothing
  
  Shirts & Tops
  Pants
  Shorts
  Activewear
  Outerwear
  Sleepwear
  Socks
- Women's Footwear
  
  Running
  Sneakers
  Sandals
  Boots
  Slippers
  All Footwear
- Men's Clothing
  
  Shirts & Tops
  Shorts
  Pants
  Activewear
  Outerwear
  Sleepwear
  Socks
- Men's Footwear
  
  Running
  Sneakers
  Sandals
  Boots
  Slippers
  All Footwear
- Kids
  
  Shirts & Tops
  Shorts
  Pants
  Outerwear
  Baby & Toddler
  Socks
  Footwear
- Accessories
  
  Hats
  Scarves
  Belts
  Jewelry
  Luggage & Bags
  Handbags, Wallets & Cases
  Gloves & Mittens
  Sunglasses
- Stores
  
  Lenny's Shoe & Apparel
  Alpine Shop
  Harbor Thread
  Dear Lucy
  Kaden Apparel
  Jennifer Khan Jewelry
  Queen City Footwear
Daily Essentials
- Pantry & Kitchen
  
  Coffee
  Tea
  Beverages
  Candy & Chocolate
  Condiments & Sauces
  Maple Products
  Seasonings & Spices
  Dips & Spreads
- Personal Care
  
  Skin Care
  Nutrition
  Bath & Body
  Bar Soap
  Cosmetics
  Hair Care
- Pet Supplies
  
  Pet Treats & Chews
  Dog Food
  Cat Food
  Grooming Supplies
  Pet Toys
- Stores
  
  Pet Food Warehouse
  Brio Coffeeworks
  Kiss the Cook
  Homeport
Home
- Household Essentials
  
  Dishcloths
  Soap
  Moisturizer
  Sunscreen
- Kitchen & Dining
  
  Cookware & Bakeware
  Knives
  Tools & Utensils
  Storage & Jars
  Appliances
  Barware & Drinkware
  Tableware
- Furniture
  
  Accent Furniture
  Dining Furniture
  Outdoor Furniture
  Office Furniture
  Upholstery
- Bedding & Bath
  
  Bedding
  Bath Towels & Washcloths
  Bathroom Accessories
  Laundry
- Home Décor
  
  Candles
  Lamps & Lighting
  Rugs & Mats
  Decorative Accents
- Stores
  
  Homeport
  Kiss the Cook
  AO Glass
  Natural Mattress Company
  Way Out Wax
Sports & Outdoors
- Hike & Camp
  
  Hiking Shirts
  Hiking Shorts
  Hiking Footwear
  Gear and Accessories
  Hydration
- Biking
  
  Bike Clothing
  Bike Accessories
  Bike Racks
- Winter Sports
  
  Ski & Snowboard Jackets
  Snowboards, Boots & Bindings
  Skis, Boots & Bindings
  Cross-Country Skis & Boots
- Stores
  
  Lenny's Shoe & Apparel
  Alpine Shop
  Queen City Footwear
Pet Supplies
- Dog Supplies
  
  Treats
  Collars & Leashes
  Beds & Crates
  Toys
- Cat Supplies
  
  Food & Treats
  Litter & Accessories
  Beds & Furniture
  Toys
- Small Animal Supplies
  
  Bird Supplies
  Food & Treats
  Habitats & Cages
- Stores
  
  Pet Food Warehouse
  Houndstooth
  Waggle Woof and Wander
  Alpine Shop
Food & Gifts
- Gourmet Foods
  
  Chocolates & Confections
  Snacks & Nuts
  Jams & Preserves
  Sauces & Condiments
  Beverages
  Maple Syrup Products
- Vermont Made
  
  Glass
  Candles
  Shoes
- Stores
  
  Magpie & Tiger
  SidePony Boutique
  Wild Lark
  Homeport
- Myti Gift Cards
Books & Hobbies
- Books & Music
  
  Fiction
  Non-Fiction
  Young Adult
  Children's Books
  Cookbooks
  Vinyl Records & LPs
- Arts & Crafts
  
  Knitting
  Crafts & Activities
- Games & Puzzles
  
  Board Games
  Puzzles
  Toys
- Stores
  
  Phoenix Books
  Autumn Records
  Must Love Yarn
  Homeport
Sale

Sign in/ Register

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube

New: See local options while browsing Amazon, Walmart & more. Learn more.

Home
|
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Collection: Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

86 products

Filter

Sort by:

Store

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont 86

Category

Baking Flavors & Extracts 1
Cereal & Granola 3
Cereal & Granola Bars 2
Cookies 5
Dessert Toppings 12
Food Gift Baskets 13
Granola Bars 1
Hot Sauce 38
Mustard 6
Salsa 2
Seasonings & Spices 2
Soups & Broths 1
Vinegar 1

Price

The highest price is $299.00 From To

From $

To $

Size

1/2 Gallon Jug 11
5 liter Bag in a Box Original Caramel 1
2oz 8
8oz 8
32oz 8
2 oz bottle 7
5 oz bottle 31
5oz bottle 1
16oz bottle 1

Allergen information

Milk 22
Mustard 10
Nuts 8
Peanuts 4
Soybeans 1
Wheat 2

Flavor

Almond 1
Apple 1
Caramel 13
Chocolate 6
Cinnamon 6
Coconut 2
Coffee 4
Ginger 4
Mint 2
Orange 2
Raspberry 1
Salted caramel 3
Vanilla 10

Dietary preferences

Alcohol-free 11
Dairy-free 4
Gluten-free 6
No artificial colors 8
No artificial flavors 8
No artificial sweeteners 1
No preservatives 10
Non-GMO 7
Nut-free 4
Organic 15
Soy-free 4
Sugar-free 3
Vegan 21
Vegetarian 23
Wholegrain 1

Sort by:

Store

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont 86

Category

Baking Flavors & Extracts 1
Cereal & Granola 3
Cereal & Granola Bars 2
Cookies 5
Dessert Toppings 12
Food Gift Baskets 13
Granola Bars 1
Hot Sauce 38
Mustard 6
Salsa 2
Seasonings & Spices 2
Soups & Broths 1
Vinegar 1

Price

The highest price is $299.00 From To

From $

To $

Size

1/2 Gallon Jug 11
5 liter Bag in a Box Original Caramel 1
2oz 8
8oz 8
32oz 8
2 oz bottle 7
5 oz bottle 31
5oz bottle 1
16oz bottle 1

Allergen information

Milk 22
Mustard 10
Nuts 8
Peanuts 4
Soybeans 1
Wheat 2

Flavor

Almond 1
Apple 1
Caramel 13
Chocolate 6
Cinnamon 6
Coconut 2
Coffee 4
Ginger 4
Mint 2
Orange 2
Raspberry 1
Salted caramel 3
Vanilla 10

Dietary preferences

Alcohol-free 11
Dairy-free 4
Gluten-free 6
No artificial colors 8
No artificial flavors 8
No artificial sweeteners 1
No preservatives 10
Non-GMO 7
Nut-free 4
Organic 15
Soy-free 4
Sugar-free 3
Vegan 21
Vegetarian 23
Wholegrain 1

Super-Hot Hot Sauce Collection by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Super-Hot Hot Sauce Collection by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Super-Hot Hot Sauce Collection

Regular price $42.00

Sale price $42.00 Regular price ~~$45.00~~

Unit price

/per

Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate

Regular price $20.00

Sale price $20.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Sriracha Essentials Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sriracha Essentials Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sriracha Essentials Set

Regular price $25.75

Sale price $25.75 Regular price ~~$28.00~~

Unit price

/per

Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler

Regular price $34.99

Sale price $34.99 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box

Regular price $34.99

Sale price $34.99 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Savory Sensation by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Savory Sensation by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Savory Sensation

Regular price $76.00

Sale price $76.00 Regular price ~~$80.00~~

Unit price

/per

Red Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Red Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Red Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce

Regular price $10.00

Sale price $10.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Peppercorn Porter Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Peppercorn Porter Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Peppercorn Porter Hot Sauce

Regular price $10.00

Sale price $10.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Parfait Partners Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Parfait Partners Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Parfait Partners Set

Regular price $29.00

Sale price $29.00 Regular price ~~$32.06~~

Unit price

/per

Mustard Lover's Gift Basket by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mustard Lover's Gift Basket

Regular price $60.00

Sale price $60.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Hot Ones Trio by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Hot Ones Trio by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Hot Ones Trio

Regular price $32.50

Sale price $32.50 Regular price ~~$35.00~~

Unit price

/per

Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit

Regular price $29.89

Sale price $29.89 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Go Green Hot Sauce Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Go Green Hot Sauce Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Go Green Hot Sauce Set

Regular price $28.00

Sale price $28.00 Regular price ~~$30.00~~

Unit price

/per

Flight of Petit Caramels by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Flight of Petit Caramels by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Flight of Petit Caramels

Regular price $50.00

Sale price $50.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Drinking Chocolate Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Drinking Chocolate Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Drinking Chocolate Kit

Regular price $28.19

Sale price $28.19 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Heady Topper Mustard by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Heady Topper Mustard by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Heady Topper Mustard

Regular price $10.00

Sale price $10.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce

Regular price $10.00

Sale price $10.00 Regular price ~~$15.00~~

Unit price

/per

DIY Caramel Apple Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

DIY Caramel Apple Kit by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

DIY Caramel Apple Kit

Regular price $23.49

Sale price $23.49 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket

Regular price $49.00

Sale price $49.00 Regular price

Unit price

/per

Cozy Tea Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cozy Tea Set by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sale

Compare

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cozy Tea Set

Regular price $36.00

Sale price $36.00 Regular price ~~$39.98~~

Unit price

/per

Join the Movement

Sign up to get involved in the Shop Local movement.

Email

You have already subscribed!

Help

Shipping & Returns Policy
Start a Return
Email Us

Policies

Privacy Policy
Terms of Use

For Shops

Vendor Login
Get on Myti

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube

© 2025 Myti. Powered by Shopify

Shipping rates display at checkout on a per-vendor basis. Many offer free delivery!

Your cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Continue shopping

Order note

Order note

Estimate Shipping

Country/region

Province

Postal/ZIP code

Coupon

Coupon

Estimated total $0.00 USD

Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout

View cart

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.